Next five countries to adopt Crypto as legal tender?

9 replies 425 views
bit420Newbie
Posts: 1 · Reputation: 35
#1Nov 16, 2024, 10:23 PM
I noticed on CMC that there's this voting section /legal-tender-countries/ that shows: Paraguay Venezuela Anguilla* Ukraine USA as the top contenders to adopt Crypto as legal tender in that order. What do you think about this list? Do you agree or not, and why? If Bitcoin becomes legal tender in these countries, does that mean it’s automatically free from taxes, or will governments still tax it like foreign currency? What if Paraguay goes ahead and makes Bitcoin legal tender first? Would that push others to follow suit? (Just a heads up, Anguilla is a tiny British Overseas Territory in the Caribbean. It's part of the Leeward Islands in the Lesser Antilles, positioned northeast of Saint Martin and the Virgin Islands.)
2 Reply Quote Share
diamond_2020Legendary
Posts: 1256 · Reputation: 6502
#2Nov 17, 2024, 02:48 AM
Unfortunately, Bitcoin is a very inconvenient coin for payments due to the long time it takes to confirm a transaction. If an analogue of the system as it was implemented in El Salvador is implemented there, then I don’t see the point. It’s probably easier to make a crypto exchange and crypto debit cards, and tax these operations.
4 Reply Quote Share
john.cobraHero Member
Posts: 408 · Reputation: 2145
#3Nov 17, 2024, 09:07 AM
Bitcoin does not have to be literally legal tender to be a legal means of payment in a country - because in most democratic countries BTC is accepted as a means of payment without being regulated in any special way. What any country in the world can learn from El Salvador is that nothing should be imposed by force, and my opinion is that BTC should be left as an alternative, not as some kind of obligation. As a rule, on-chain transactions are not instant, but there is an LN that enables instant and super cheap transactions, and this is exactly what El Salvador used, so the problem was not in the speed or price of transactions, but in the fact that people simply did not accept Bitcoin as a better alternative to the US dollar, which is the official currency in that country.
2 Reply Quote Share
the_kingHero Member
Posts: 435 · Reputation: 2048
#4Nov 17, 2024, 10:14 AM
I want, legally legitimately I want to see all countries using bitcoin payment tools legally legally and rules, if that happens to all countries, I think people are reluctant to use bitcoin to pay a cup of their coffee. I think Bitcoin is good to use as an investment, trade, open as a means of payment, taxes, more expensive costs with the goods you buy. Coffee price is $ 2 while your tax and cost spend $ 5 dollars, it's a real joke that must be faced by Bitcoin users.
2 Reply Quote Share
w0lf404Hero Member
Posts: 801 · Reputation: 2381
#5Nov 17, 2024, 03:48 PM
Unless we start using LN, we will always have to face the delay and cost issues which is a real challenge. Being a Bitcoin user of more than 10 years, I wouldn't honestly prefer bitcoin payment over a debit card. Simply because a debit card payment is cheaper and faster. However, it is always beneficial to have a favorable legal framework. It usually paves the way to bring in innovative solutions to the table.
3 Reply Quote Share
dave_satoshiSenior Member
Posts: 119 · Reputation: 874
#6Nov 17, 2024, 07:25 PM
Bitcoin scalability issue can be mitigated by moving to Layer-2 solutions like LN, which addresses the scalability issue and also reduces the fee. The real issue in bitcoin adoption is that government's not willing to allow any financial system to operate which they can't monitor and manipulate. What we have seen so far is that government's are adopting only centralised Bitcoin, i.e., bitcoin going through centralised exchanges with KYC.
3 Reply Quote Share
the_matrixSenior Member
Posts: 313 · Reputation: 1887
#7Nov 20, 2024, 04:29 AM
I don't know why people are concerned about BTC being a legal tender, take note that this is something that is not in our hands and we have no control over, it is up to the respective country to decide if they want to make BTC a legal tender. Currently, there is no country were BTC is even a legal tender, because El Salvador has revoked their BTC legal tender law. BTC is already legal in most countries, and in my opinion that is enough, as long as people can use and spend BTC. I am even shocked to find the U.S. on the list, they are the last country that could make BTC a legal tender, for obvious reasons.
2 Reply Quote Share
ben2021Member
Posts: 33 · Reputation: 236
#8Nov 20, 2024, 07:35 AM
It is possible that any of those countries could adopt Bitcoin as a payment tool irrespective of confirmation time. It is not very correct to say that the payment confirmation time for BTC is too long. Afterall, the network can notify the recepient when a transaction has been detected and even state how much was sent. I think that this function can be improved further, especially if it was ascertained that the sender paid enough fees to enable confirmation of the transaction. This notification should be enough incentive to approve the transaction at merchant level.
0 Reply Quote Share
dave_satoshiSenior Member
Posts: 119 · Reputation: 874
#9Nov 21, 2024, 12:28 PM
Bitcoin was introduced as an independent entity for p2p electronic cash transfer without involvement of middlemen. With passage of time, people from around the world join the Bitcoin community and this resulted in increase in it's price and adoption. So far there are many countries where Bitcoin is not legal compared to countries which have allowed use of Bitcoin but that's not a concern for Bitcoin since it has grown and survived without the aid and support of governments. If any country is adopting Bitcoin as legal tender then it's their own choice not Bitcoin request.
1 Reply Quote Share
the_matrixSenior Member
Posts: 313 · Reputation: 1887
#10Nov 21, 2024, 05:15 PM
That is not true, BTC is legal in most countries, i don't mean a legal tender, it is legal because the citizens can buy, sell, trade and even spend BTC with merchants that accept it, however merchants are not obliged to accept it as they would with a legal tender. There would be many countries setting up a BTC reserve and getting involved with BTC in someway, but it would be difficult to think of a country that would want to make BTC a legal tender.
2 Reply Quote Share

Related topics