Could we set up a thread just for trading signals on this forum? I'm keen to start one for that.
Can we make this happen?
19 replies 443 views
diamond365Full Member
Posts: 136 · Reputation: 744
#2Nov 29, 2021, 10:03 PM
Is it your company or individual service?
You can create your service announcement thread in either Service announcement for Bitcoin and Service announcement for altcoins.
Service announcements: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?board=84.0
Service announcements (Altcoins): https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?board=197.0
If it is purely a signal for discussion and things like pump and dump effort, I don't think it has value for discussion and it can be deleted.
I don't like signals that are for pumps and dumps.
alex.shardLegendary
Posts: 1019 · Reputation: 5623
#3Dec 1, 2021, 10:20 AM
Is it a paid or free signal?
If it is a paid signal, no one on this forum will believe you. But if it is free signal, they will believe you. But will you be able to be accurate in the signal is another thing.
If you want to offer a paid signal, come with at least a month of free daily signals with no inaccuracies. No one has been able to be accurate among those that have come with signals before on this forum.
Basically it depends on your purpose of giving signals, if it's just sharing analysis ( mapping ) for discussion, that's great. but if what you mean is paid signals it's not a good plan buddy, there will be risks and responsibilities that you bear if your analysis is wrong or does not run according to the price in the market, you know the market is very volatile.
When you make a thread later, maybe we can discuss together about the coin you analyzed, i know a little bit about this, more precisely my basic techincal analysis since 2017, LOL.
You can create it here, but can the trading signal be really accurate and can help everyone to achieve maximum profit in trading? Because so far the market conditions are often uncertain when there is news that has an effect on influencing the market. So as long as the thread you want to create can produce more benefits for everyone, of course it's okay for you to create it, but if it's just a trap for everyone, I don't think you need to create it specifically.
quantumsageFull Member
Posts: 118 · Reputation: 424
#6Dec 2, 2021, 09:44 AM
You can create a thread dedicated to trading signals but some people don't trust paid ones which they consider a scam.
Try here you share how you trade when the techniques you do are really accurate then people will believe and maybe follow the way of trading like you.
If about free trading signals I have followed many including on telegram and discord but none of them are accurate more spread news information than technical.
I don't think anyone will frown at that idea of yours, provided they're free signals you're giving and you won't want to take anyone away from this forum. After all, people hardly reject freebies. You can only run into problems if by design you try to ask for money or ask members to join your paid group on Telegram/Twitter or on any other SM platform you created. I for one will like to visit any thread where accurate live trading signals are shared.
QuantumYieldSenior Member
Posts: 117 · Reputation: 813
#8Dec 2, 2021, 03:45 PM
It is allowed but not with referal link.
You can do your searching homework before asking too. My quick search gives me some threads about trading signals, and it's clearly that you can find more.
Meme coins signals group here
Finally Buy Sell Signals That Actually Work - Free TV indicator (Noob Friendly)
AutoCryptoAlerts Telegram trade signals: order blocks, divergences & trends
Traders who are relied on trading signals of other traders, are not good and independent traders at all. If they are not good with trading, don't trade, and don't rely on trading signals that can be bad ones and scam too.
block_2018Senior Member
Posts: 155 · Reputation: 949
#9Dec 2, 2021, 09:45 PM
Not doubting your trading, but mostly trading signals to attract to the group you created right? After a lot of interest there will usually be a premium rate to the signal.
But if you want to share your trading experience then please do so in this forum we would love to hear how you did it especially with accuracy.
Honestly for trading itself does not require any trading signals but rely on their own skills.
mr_satoshiSenior Member
Posts: 305 · Reputation: 1629
#10Dec 3, 2021, 02:25 AM
If you are a trader and you want to show the forum that you have results from your signals, nobody will penalize or criticize you for it. You will face criticism when you have the intention to make money from forum members by referring them to a link outside of the forum and demanding a fee.
In the forum, we encourage members who are interested in trading to try to learn to trade on their own and not depend on signal groups.
You can create a thread to discuss about trading signal but it shouldn't be something you have to do as fee for you to share any information on the topic or thread. All discussion must be open here and no discussion aside this forum for transparency otherwise it would lead to scam and since forum aren't moderating scam it's on their own risk for having discussions outside this forum.
Of course yes. This sub board is specifically for trading discussions that permits whatever thread having to do with trading in and outside the forum.
coin_sigmaLegendary
Posts: 1275 · Reputation: 5553
#13Dec 3, 2021, 04:34 PM
If this is all about Bitcoin trading and prediction, I think the speculation section is the right place to make this thread.
Just make sure the signals you are going to provide are detailed.
Trading discussion is not the right place for signal we should talks about on trading-related topics, not for speculating since giving a signal is a part of prediction.
If this is not only Bitcoin and talks about altcoin, then you can make a thread in the "Altcoin speculation section".
Probably brace yourself nevertheless even if you offer free signals as you will still face skepticism from members.
For instance: they could wonder if a fee will be set later down the line once it becomes popular or worse, will be used for a pump and dump scheme. There has been too many shady things surrounding signals that people just have become skeptical in general, IMO.
But yeah, as pointed out, creating a thread should be fine.
king_oracleMember
Posts: 38 · Reputation: 206
#15Dec 6, 2021, 04:12 AM
If you can give accurate trading signals, that too for free, then you can open a thread here. If your signals are accurate, then people can follow you and if they are not accurate, then people will not follow you. People do not trust other people's signals very much, people always trust their own signals.
Crypto market is uncertain, there is no guarantee that you can give correct signal. Now if someone buys and profits from your signalnel, they will thank you. But on the other hand, if someone buys a coin on your signal and suffers a loss, they can blame you. And giving proper signal is very difficult, I don't think anyone will be interested in your signal, but newbies may be interested. I have seen some telegram channels that they charge some fee for giving signal. However, if you can offer free signals, if 2-1 signals are good, many may show interest.
wh4le_2014Full Member
Posts: 23 · Reputation: 271
#17Dec 8, 2021, 06:18 AM
Your trading signals will be free or paid? if it will free i think it's fine, many traders in the forum, so if you can provide free signals but if will accurate then everyone will follow your signals but if wrong signals, people's will reject your signals and will blame you for any losses in their trades.
The forum is ready to accommodate everyone as long you're here to give a positive impact, throwing into positivity contributing ideas and development. Ofcourse it will be a valid thread as long as the signals are free. You do know how broad this forum have grown all these years to become. Try as much as possible not to ruined the good reputation you're trying to build at this early stage turn into something else. Paid signals are big red flag on the forum because literally everyone is aware of scams since it becomes the orders of the day. We trade because we're open to generate profits, paying for signals seems sketchy to most people.
If it's a free signal thread where you will steadily post the trades you are taking, it's a good idea but for the sake of not misleading some person, you will have to put a disclaimer stating the risk involving and that you will not be held responsible for the losses members taking your provided signals.
You can create a thread for trading signals here but there is no guarantee of how effective it will be. Not all signal providers are reliable some may consider them scams and some signals may be wrong or fraudulent. The market is always volatile making it difficult to provide accurate information. Trading using signals may lack your own analysis which is risky. Relying on others to trade reduces your control over your own decisions.
?Reply
Sign in to reply to this topic
Related topics
- Did you actually understand what CZ meant? 19
- Do you simulate before launching arbitrage bots? 19
- What's your favorite trading style: Scalping, Day trading, or Swing trading? 19
- Analyzing Crypto Options: GEX, Flip Zones, Gamma Walls for Traders 1
- Which app is this for portfolio tracking? 9
- 97% of day traders end up losing cash 19